Create account

2857d · Capitalism
Because Stalin, or whatever? Yes, one of the worst mass murders the human race had ever seen. One of the champions of communism. Yes that helps show how communism is evil.
replied 2857d
Saying that Stalin is one of the champions of communism is as meaningless as saying that Pinochet is a champion of capitalism. Definitions matter. Communism is the collective...
replied 2856d
Communism claims to be the collective, but in reality it is still a small group pushing their agenda on others. They claim to represent the people.
replied 2856d
Communism is not a claim. It's a concept or an ideology. One could argue that it's a concept that does not work in reality, but a concept is not a claim.
replied 2855d
Those seeking communism make a claim, but the reality never matches that claim. State communism is the only real communism ever tried.
replied 2857d
....ownership of property. Stalinism is the state ownership of property. There is a difference between state capitalism and communism.
replied 2856d
Stalin was state communism, not state capitalism. State capitalism is modern day South Korea. The only real communism is state communism. Collective communism is a lie.
replied 2856d
"State capitalism is modern day South Korea."
Ummm, no? Do definitions not mean anything to you? Or are we calling all mixed economies state capitalism? Is the UK state capitalist?
replied 2855d
The UK is just capitalist. As for state communism, that is what all communist nations are. No private property rights, with the state giving direction.
replied 2855d
Definitions mean something, and so I use them. South Korea is a top down capitalism. The state chose which monopolies they wish to support. The state directs the markets there.
replied 2855d
Every government subsidizes their key industries and monopolies. Research US and corn subsidies, telecom monopolies, the UK and the RBS fiasco or the Government Pension Fund of Norway.
replied 2855d
Every nation backs it's own agriculture so that if the worst case scenarios happen a nation can feed itself.
replied 2855d
Your claims have no basis in reality.

The US, UK, Sweden, China, and South Korea are both mixed economies. They exist on a spectrum of control and free market.
replied 2855d
Here is some backgroundinfo:
replied 2855d
Of course. I didn't mean to imply otherwise. I was talking about how South Korean capitalism is different. State directed from the top down to keep the monopolies they back.