Create account

replied 2267d
Nations (plural) is mutually exclusive to global government.
The absence of optionality seems like a defining characteristic of government in general.
replied 2267d
You can have nations under a global government the same way you have provinces and states under a federal government. It would just be an additional layer.
replied 2267d
Sort of like the UN then, but with more power over nation states? What areas of life would it dictate? If a religion gains global majority, could it impose religious law globally?
replied 2266d
Global laws would likely only apply to nations, and global entities. Things done of oceans, etc.
replied 2266d
It seems we already have that, with the U.N. and similar treaties.
replied 2265d
Almost. The UN has no real enforcement ability though. They give a strongly worded letter to nations that break the rules. Also they dont give jurisdiction on international waters.
replied 2265d
I think you have to make up your mind. Either one of the global government or the nation state needs to have final say.
replied 2265d
I did make it up. A global government should have the authority to hold nations to a constitution. Restricting the powers of national governments over their people.
replied 2264d
So the global government could only act with force against national governments and not against individuals?
replied 2264d
Yes, at least in how I would like to see it. Restricting governments from abusing their people. Freedom of movement to prevent nations like North Korea from enslaving their people
replied 2263d
Would it restrict national governments from stealing from their people?
replied 2263d
If they out that in there, sure. Depends what you mean by stealing though. Please dont say taxation is theft as it is a failed argument built on false premises.
replied 2263d
Taxation is theft.
replied 2263d
Taxation is payment for services rendered. You can always leave the taxable area and live on your own. Staying in the taxable are is your choice.
replied 2263d
This theory negates the idea of private property.
replied 2263d
No it doesn't at all. If you purchase property in a taxable area then you consent to taxation.
replied 2263d
Then it shouldn't be called private property. It's more like a rental really.
replied 2263d
How is it not private property? Paying taxes doesn't mean it isn't yours. Not paying for services is theft.
replied 2263d
It's not legally yours if it can be legally taken away. I have a service you haven't paid for. Have you stolen from me?
replied 2263d
Ok, I feel I've lost you. How can your property be taken away? How does that make any difference when we talk about living within the taxable area?
replied 2263d
If you don't pay the extortion fee, your property will be taken away, whether it's the money in your bank acct or your real estate. I consider Earth my taxable area.
replied 2263d
That happens if you dont pay taxes in the US? Maybe this is more of an American problem. My uncle owes about 2 mil in taxes and doesn't go to jail, or have property taken.
replied 2263d
If there are no consequences for not paying then it seems the concept of taxation loses its meaning.
replied 2263d
If people are paying taxes without threat of jail time, in Canada at least, then it shows taxation is not theft, at least outside the US. I am starting to think the IRS is absurd.
replied 2263d
What is your opinion? What should be the consequences for not paying taxes?
replied 2263d
The British learned how wrong it is to jail people for any kind of debts long ago. I guess the US left the British system though and went to enforcing taxation with jail time.
replied 2263d
They phone you and send you strongly worded letter asking for their money. Like any bill collector. I suspect British Commknwealth nations all do this.
replied 2261d
"HMRC criminal investigation officers have wide-ranging powers of arrest, entry, search and detention."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HM_Revenue_and_Customs#Powers_of_officers
replied 2261d
Looks like they go after smugglers. What is your point?
replied 2260d
"department of the UK Government responsible for the collection of taxes"
This guy was executed for tax evasion:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Harding_(forger)
replied 2260d
This link also doesn't work. I am really doubting this one.
replied 2259d
You really can't figure out where this link goes?
replied 2259d
Okay I followed the link. It makes my point for me. Britain has a bad history with debtors jail. They got rid of people being jailed for debts.
replied 2259d
Lol. People get jailed for tax evasion today, and in the past even executed. Your point is void. Read the articles.
replied 2257d
So as I said. People are not jailed for it everywhere. Lots of times it takes extreme circumstances. That said you are morally obligated to pay taxes if you benefit from them.
replied 2254d
I benefit from maybe 10% of the activities that my taxes fund. So I'm only obligated to pay those 10%? How about compensation for the 90% of tax activities that make my life worse?
replied 2254d
You are not evaluating your benefits properly. The benefits that others receive directly do affect you indirectly. Living in a stable and prosperous area is a benefit.
replied 2259d
I read one of them. Like I said though. I only suspected it of other Commonwealth nations.
replied 2263d
Well, if taxes are voluntary, they're not really taxes, are they? I suspect there are state-enforced consequences though, like being barred from starting a company.
replied 2263d
Why would their voluntary nature make them no longer taxes? The definition of taxation does not require them to not be voluntary.
replied 2261d
"A failure to pay, along with evasion of or resistance to taxation, is punishable by law."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax
replied 2261d
I never said they were not mandatory. I just said they dont put you in jail for not paying. I know this for Canada. I suspect it for the British Commonwealth.
replied 2260d
"Convicted for tax evasion, he was sentenced in November 1990 to nine months in jail."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Davenport_(fraudster)#Gatecrasher_Balls
replied 2260d
The link doesn't work. What country is he from? My uncle owes 2 million in unpaid taxes. No jail.
replied 2263d
They stop giving you your GST returns, and other tax returns, and count that as payments toward your debt. It also messes with your credit rating. Either way they are still taxes.