Create account

replied 2267d
over introducing each new planet? I don’t care if it’s lifted, that makes the new material (ie Star Wars) more accessible. I care that it doesnt fit in a Star Wars movie.
replied 2267d
Really, a poor phone connection joke? Breaks the setting & makes the first order look even more like bumbling buffoons.
Sk8eM dUb
replied 2267d
Phone jokes are classic Star Wars. There were TWO phone jokes in the original.
replied 2259d
We’re not watching the rebels fight for their lives we’re watching a bunch of actors have a laugh about how crazy awesome it is to be in a Star Wars movie.
replied 2259d
the problem is, in the quest to subvert expectations nothing is sincere. everything is ironic. everything is a joke. everything is meta.
Sk8eM dUb
replied 2259d
"the quest to subvert expectations" is a myth. The silliness juxtaposed with despair/turmoil is a device echoed directly from Attack of the Clones.
replied 2246d
And really the issue here is not subverting expectations of plot (though that is still annoying) it’s subverting expectations of basic story flow. The movie includes too much
replied 2246d
inappropriate bathos - continual breaks in mood. Always undercutting any serious situation with a joke. Would have been if Vader made a dad joke after telling Luke he was his father
replied 2246d
It is an ironic detachment. Self-referential jokes made to excuse the fact that the story is poorly written. “Cant think of a better plot point than a giant space laser, again?
replied 2246d
Just make a self-referential joke about it & move on with the rehashed plot.”
replied 2246d
replied 2246d
replied 2246d
"the object is not to subvert expectation" - Rian Johnson. Maybe his intention was not to subvert expectations but the result did
replied 2246d