Create account

anarchovegan
replied 2252d
Staying on earth (because pretty much everywhere is a tax farm now) validates being stolen from, because you benefitted from previous work not done explicitly for you?
replied 2252d
To a certain degree though, yes it does. Humans are social creatures, and we have put a lot of work into civilization. Humans expect other humans to contribute. We are social creatures
anarchovegan
replied 2252d
It does? Isn't systematic stealing ("contributing") an anti-social activity?
replied 2252d
The only theft is by those not paying their taxes while living off of the benefits of them. It is theft from the community. This leaves the society free to reject you.
anarchovegan
replied 2252d
Doesn't monopolization prevent the ability to make alternatives to use instead, such as the roads? Health care?
Doesn't this decrease efficiency?
replied 2252d
Yes, and no. Healthcare is an example how? How is this related to the idea of taxation as theft though? Many different nations have different competing systems over time.
anarchovegan
replied 2252d
Are you not familiar with the welfare state, Obamacare, and such?
Healthcare related to taxation.
replied 2252d
I am familiar with how it helps the system and reduces costs. It made things more efficient. That said Obamacare is a right wing healthcare system. Single payer would have been better.
anarchovegan
replied 2252d
So, those who reject the idea of taxation based on its involuntary nature and speak out against it as a violation of consent, aren't being stolen from?
replied 2252d
No they are not. They are just being dramatic. Especially considering the untrue nature of the premises their argument stand on.
anarchovegan
replied 2252d
And how it is untrue that they are being stolen from?
replied 2252d
It is a trade that the people have agreed upon communally. Attempting to live there without paying taxes would be the only real theft. Leaving would be how you would avoid stealing.
replied 2252d
Not everywhere. There are lots of places one can go. Many still within national borders letting you still benefit a small amount for free. Lots of land outside of civilization.