Create account

White men are people too
replied 2230d
You said some words, but they were not an explanation. You just kept making the same mistake over and over, the one that I exemplified with red and blue jackets.
1 / 52
replied 2230d
Your red and blue jacket analogy made no sense at all. It did not fit our conversation in any way. It was mostly jibberish.
White men are people too
replied 2230d
There you go repeating unfounded assertions again. You are a Animal Farm goat.
replied 2229d
How is that repeating? It wasn't an apology at all. I never made anything close to the claims you did in that analogy.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
You repeated the unfounded assertion that my example did not fit what you had been saying. You just claim claim claim, you never back things up, instead you repeat.
replied 2229d
I've backed it up. You refuse to acknowledge it. You are just repeating yourself now though.
1
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Now you repeat that you have backed it up. As already said, all you did was repeat the aforementioned red/blue jackets fallacy a few times with different words.
replied 2229d
I never made that fallacy at all. I never said anything even close to that fallacy. You just asserted an unrelated fallacy for no reason.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Let me spoon feed that to you. I draw a parallel between two things, A and B. You pick a characteristic c of A and claim B does have exactly c, therefore the parallel is flawed.
replied 2229d
You failed to draw a parallel, and then acted as if you didn't fail.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
So again, you just repeat, while I am spoon feeding you the explanation of how you have not really shown anything. Maybe you don't understand logic?
replied 2229d
You are not explaining at all. I do understand logic well enough. Obviously the limited character terms makes complete explanations difficult though.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
And "you are not explaining at all", that is totally unreasonable. I am explaining and you are ignoring the explanation and talking about other things.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
"I do understand logic well enough", still, you just ignored what I said, and repeated yourself. If you understand the logic, answer what I said, don't just talk about something else.
replied 2229d
I didn't ignore what you said. In your example the characteristic c was what was being compared. So it doesn't help to compare A and B by dissimilar qualities.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
In my example c was almost exactly the same as what was being compared, but the wording was slightly different. A parody of what you said, sure, but still valid
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Stop lying. You just repeated yourself, instead of answering what I said.
replied 2229d
Your example of jackets talking about who you can learn from had zero to do with our conversation though.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Again, you keep repeating stuff without any explanation. Why do you do this? How could you possibly think this helps after all I have said about repetition before this?
White men are people too
replied 2229d
You have not shown that c is critical for the parallel between A and B, and when I point this out, you instead repeat that B does not have c.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
My example with the jackets would have made this clear to a thinking individual. I am starting to suspect you are not one.
replied 2229d
Did you fail logic class? I didn't. You compared things that are not easily comparably in the exact way you compared him. No I didn't explain why in these limited characters.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
So now they are not "easily" comparable? Does that mean they are comparable? No, I didn't fail logic class, but you are failing to follow simple logic in another thread
replied 2229d
Whatever. This thole hinges has become hypothetical talk about words. I think that is because the actual point was too much.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Your sentences are becoming almost as hazy as your logic here. "The actual point" was never explained, as you now are starting to admit (you denied it before).
replied 2229d
Did you forget the original conversation this came from? It was about comparing control of a border with control of your house.

There are ways to compare those and ways that dont work
White men are people too
replied 2229d
And no, I did not forget the original conversation. Did you just add that question there to make the repetition of an old assertion look good? Because repeat is all you did in the end
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Did you forget that you argued like there are NO way to compare those? You said things like it showed I was not thinking. Again you repeat it don't work, without explaining.
replied 2229d
Homes dont have populations to sustain. Shrinking populations provide less tax revenue for an aging population. They also prevent projects due to insufficient population.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Projects may also be prevented because of infighting between immigrants and non immigrants.
replied 2229d
Maybe... interesting hypothetical. Usually having people who want to get paid to work helps the work happen though.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Therefore the first comment I had on all this stuff. We have no proof that they will want to get paid. If they get by on welfare, they may choose to stick with it
White men are people too
replied 2229d
They may choose to steal instead of working. They may want to work but not be able to do anything useful.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
The tax revenue may be improving with immigration, but it may not matter. As I said long ago, it is not given that immigration gives a net plus for economy of a country.
replied 2229d
Actually it is a well established given that immigrants are good for the economy. They are more likely to start a business, and buy gigs like everyone else.
Sk8eM dUb
replied 2229d
the people included in your statistic are the ones who went through the long and expensive process of immigrating legally. Canada has a big beautiful wall between you and Mexico btw.
replied 2229d
That actually included all forms of immigration
Not all refugees are poor. Just displaced by war. Often wars we started, and so should bear some responsibility for.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
I suppose you know all about the literature on this? You have read it all and made an overview of it all have you? I was told differently.
replied 2229d
Actually yes, I have. Not to any major extent, but enough to know that immigration is good for the economy. The bring money to the nation.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
OK, sorry if I don't believe a word of what you are saying here.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Also, the immigration on a massive scale that is happening in Europe today, it is an experiment that is hard to predict the outcome of. One claim is that they will not integrate well
White men are people too
replied 2229d
A few immigrants have to bend to the will of the people living in a country. When they become many, they will set their own demands. Muslims for example have their own culture
White men are people too
replied 2229d
The Koran specifically sets muslim men on top, then muslim women, then the whites. Those who follow the koran have no intention of caring for us when we get old
replied 2229d
I think I see where you have blinders on. You see Muslims as some kind of threat. I see Christian's as being a similar threat, but dont think we should kick them out.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Blinders? This just gets dumber and dumber. You seem to be totally unaware (blinders?) of what has happened in Sweden, France, Germany, Britain etc. with Muslim gangs.
replied 2229d
I know lots of people fall for fake, and sensational news. Gangs exist everywhere. Often the biggest problem you hear about are not coming from the recent immigrants.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
The recent ones? Who cares if they are recent? Maybe you should watch this to learn something about what real people experience.
replied 2229d
You are an immigrant...
White men are people too
replied 2229d
I suppose you refer to "we are all immigrants if we go far enough back". Irrelevant to this thread, and a silly argument. But more important, did you watch the movie?
replied 2229d
You ever hear what is written on the statue of liberty?
White men are people too
replied 2229d
If you had a point and was able to make it, I would be willing to listen. But you like pretending to have an argument instead. Just say what you want to say already
replied 2229d
You are just repeating your same nonsense now. I get it, you cant actually refute the loi vs. You just hand wave them away like LightRider would.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
the "loi vs."? You seriously need to learn to write down what you think
replied 2229d
I need to read what I type before hitting post more... I think I was going for "refute the points."
replied 2229d
I'm not going to waste my time watching that right now. I am mostly talking about people in North America. Especially the US which was built through immigration.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
You were talking in general terms in the topic. Now you have chanced your stance again. I understand that you don't want to watch that, you might learn something about the truth
replied 2229d
Yes, when talking about global freedom of movement I was. Right here we were talking about the ignorance of complaining about immigration while living in North America.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
How do you figure that? Where did we state North America?
replied 2229d
It became that when I mentioned that you are an immigrant, and when mentioning what is written on the statue of liberty.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
Ah, I chose to ignore that particular unfounded assumption. Apparently you took that as a confirmation and an acceptance of your constant attempts to derail the conversation.
replied 2228d
I am not derailing the conversation. You did that long ago.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
Lies are not helpful. Shame on you.
replied 2228d
You derailed the conversation with your comparison. Then refusing to accept the reasons your comparison failed. It is all on you.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
I make comparisons to help you understand the failure of your logic. You try to make this into "you are an American huh huh" and similar things. All on YOU
replied 2228d
I never made it about you being American. If your done repeating yourself you might try to make a point.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Easier to claim that others have blinds and go on repeating your own stuff, never really listening to what others say. Do you even understand what having "blinds" involves?
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Oh, and of course stuff that does not happen in North America is irrelevant, nothing to learn from other places, cause parallels do not exist in your world
replied 2229d
When talking about globalism or most anything for that matter, it is wrong to think America is the only topic that matters.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
So here you have a total logical breakdown again. You were saying you refused to watch a movie that was not about North America. Obviously my comment is about that.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
If you don't think America is the only topic that matters, your "reason" for not watching the movie falls away. Maybe you should watch it then.
replied 2229d
I dont have time right now is the reason.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
And remember, you want more immigration, that will increase the problem.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Families can also shrink, and it could be argued you should allow some bums into your house to adjust for this. To increase the household income. A bum may have some small allowance
replied 2229d
The funny part of that compairons is that often immigrants are the middle class who could afford to emigrate their nation, and set up in another. So bum doesn't really apply.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
They may be bums, they may not. Just because they were rich at home does not mean they will be in their new country. Typically rather young boys come, and they are not workers/bums yet
replied 2229d
Sure, it is fine for people to come live in your home. Since you like this comparison I am sure you would hardly notice these people in your home as you have millions living there.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
This is just totally off the scale. You are the one arguing in favor of importing (OK, since you are too dumb to understand that word, "allowing entrance of") immigrants.
replied 2229d
What do you know. Scale makes your comparison break down, just as I was saying.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
No, "this is off the scale" as in very stupid statement. You ask others to accept immigrants, and now say it is fine for people to live in my home. The question is about YOUR home.
replied 2229d
Off the scale? As for my home country yes I like immigrants. I am one of the only white home owners on my street. Many other white people are renters in basement suites.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Fascinating story I'm sure. So, do you understand that I am asking you if you have invited bums to live in your living-room?
replied 2229d
I understand that. It is completely irrelevant to this issue of course. It shows just how much you dont understand what is being discussed.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
You understand it, but still just talked as if it was about me accepting immigrants in my country or bums in my home. Do you hold your nose with one hand while typing this manure?
replied 2229d
You were he only one talking as if it was about accepting bums in your home. Are you acknowledging how shitty your idea was?
White men are people too
replied 2229d
So you are back to repeating your unfounded assertion that my parallel is wrong I see. Shame on you.
replied 2229d
How could you see that as repeating my earlier points? Are you reading something else and then replying to the wrong comment? That I could understand. I was correcting you this time.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Wrong again. My idea that you should allow bums into your living area is directly based on the parallel that you have so much trouble with. It is quite simple from a logical pov
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Do you want me to explain it to you? It is trivial, but I can explain it if you can't manage.
replied 2228d
Please do, especially since it is your misunderstanding that leads to his idea.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
You think western democracies "must" accept immigrants. They come into our "home" (homeland), and the question then arises, what if they act like bums? Since you do not see the problem
White men are people too
replied 2228d
I use the parallel of normal homes, and ask if you accept bums into your living area. Do you get it now?
replied 2228d
No wonder you cant actually see the issue. You are so hung up on people immigrating to western countries.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
OK, you are claiming that western countries should allow immigration, and then you claim I can't actually see the issue because I am hung up on people immigrating to western countries
replied 2228d
Repeating your strawman. I've said it enough. You can argue or fail.
replied 2228d
Ah, that is where you are confused. I said all countries, not just western countries. Also it was about coming, and going. Not just western countries accepting immigrants.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
Who said "just" western countries? Are western countries not part of "People should be free to go where they wish"?
replied 2228d
You already failed.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
You didn't hear me. Why are you now talking about "just" western countries? What relevance does that have?
replied 2228d
I'm not. You are. I mentioned America because you kept wanting to make it about western countries. I was just mentioning it is un-American to be against immigration.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
The only real political pressure to accept lots of refugees that I know about to is on western democracies. I cannot talk for other countries, so I talked about what I knew.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
I do not try to make it about western countries, but when I make a statement that I am not sure goes for all countries, I naturally limit the list.
replied 2228d
I have seen many refugees express, in interviews on youtube, their gratitude to European countries and citizens for accepting them when their own muslim neighbors wouldn't.
replied 2228d
Western nations are some of the only nations that accept refugees as far as I know. My freedom of movement is more about nations that dont let people leave. North Korea for example.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
What you said earlier was something to the effect that it was wrong to be against immigration. It seemed to cover the current resistance in western countries against mass immigration
replied 2228d
America was meant to be a bastion of freedom for people fleeing oppressive nations. Like I said, read what is written on the Statue of Liberty.
1
546
replied 2228d
That or in the case of the USA, which always had a policy of taking on refugees, and immigrants from all over. In the US is is almost cliche that immigrants come and start a business.
replied 2228d
Mass immigration isn't even a real thing. War refugees are a different issue though. Africa took in a lot of European refugees during the world wars so it is wrong for Europe to say no
White men are people too
replied 2228d
First, I don't accept your assertion that mass immigration is not a real thing. You should show how it is not. Second, the large wave of immigrants that came to Europe recently...
replied 2228d
It isn't enough people to be considered "mass immigration." Also people returning home after fighting has settled down doesn't mean they were not refugees.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
Enough people to become majority in a few decades is not mass immigration? You really think this? These are projections for current immigration policy for several western countries.
replied 2227d
The reason anyone else would become the majority is actually due to low birth rates of people from those nations. People dont have enough babies. People need to have at least 3.
White men are people too
replied 2227d
If everyone did this, the population explosion would be a bigger and bigger problem. Also, it is not wrong for populations to shrink. We have been through this before. Did you forget?
replied 2227d
I know you showed your ignorance before.
White men are people too
replied 2227d
OK. You keep being wrong, which not so bad, but then you are obnoxious about it, which is not fine. I noticed you backed off when I asked you to give me your best argument properly.
replied 2227d
I didn't back off. I'm just not repeating myself. I gave you the argument in the form of your formula, and the actual example laid out. I'm not going to dumb it down anymore.
White men are people too
replied 2227d
Instead you spend your time being obnoxious
White men are people too
replied 2228d
From what you have said so far it seems you want a even more liberal policy, where these countries would be flooded with immigrants in maybe one decade, until they broke down
replied 2227d
What makes you think everyone would move if they could? Most people like to stay home, unless home is not a good place to live.
White men are people too
replied 2227d
Population explosions in Africa are projected to lead to much more people wanting to move than now actually. In general, Africa is not a good place to live compared to the west
White men are people too
replied 2228d
Already there are quite some signs of what's to come. Sharia courts for example are in place today in Britain(not above British law, but still operating as if being legal institutions)
White men are people too
replied 2228d
Or you could look to South Africa, where white farmers now are being killed for being white, even a politician singing from stage stuff that strongly suggests killing of whites.
replied 2227d
Most of this is actually fake news. The right are very susceptible to propaganda.
White men are people too
replied 2227d
Your assertion. The singing is provable.

Used to be directly "kill the boer".
The left is just as susceptible to propaganda.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
it was sold to us as refugees, but later it has been shown that the majority was not. Many go back to their home countries on vacation for example. Those who were refugees from long
White men are people too
replied 2228d
ago, they mostly stay in the European countries even when wars stop in their home countries. They have not plans to go back. Very different from majority of WWI/II refugees
replied 2228d
Yeah, and if the new country offers better opportunities then they go for that. That is not a bad thing.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
Whether it is a bad thing or not is not relevant. The point is it is different. Taking care of a group for a short while is very different from being stuck with them forever
replied 2227d
Those who dont return often left because of persecution. Those who return left because their homes were not safe. They are more likely to return after.
White men are people too
replied 2227d
This is irrelevant. Se another reply.
replied 2227d
Nothing wrong with different at all.
White men are people too
replied 2227d
So, I will use my parallel again. I let you stay in my house for 1 hour because you are cold. Then I demand that you now let me stay in your house forever. Fair?
White men are people too
replied 2228d
Also, you really should read up on demographics for the region. Some estimates give muslim majority in about half a century. If you look at what trouble they already have with distinct
White men are people too
replied 2228d
minorities, this is a very serious thing. Again you should watch the movie I linked to. It shows some of the things you can expect with radical Islam in a western country
replied 2229d
Private property is owned by an individual. Nations are public property and governments in a way manage that property. Only a portion dislike immigration.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
This is not answering what I said. Also it does not make much sense to me.
replied 2229d
I am listing which inckmpatabilitirs makes the comparison fall apart.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Ah, you are back to repeating the old argument with the big hole in it. Maybe I should have guessed. Feeling impolite yet?
replied 2229d
You have yet to actually respond to the argument. I dont think you can. You just keep hand waving it away.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Wrong again. As all the other stuff you say. I keep explaining in many different ways, you have not said HOW your big words like "private vs public" makes a difference. You just assert
replied 2229d
Homes dont have military battles over neighbouring borders. Disputes over fences go to local governments. In a home a squatter can displace you. Immigrants dont come in those numbers.
replied 2229d
I did explain. Comparing how you manage who comes I to your home to how you control who come and leave a country doesn't work. There are ways to compare nations to homes, not that one.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
No, as with this very comment, you just repeat. You do not say WHY it does not work. You just repeat the assertion.
replied 2229d
These are the reasons why comparing nations to homes cant be compared for border control.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
So now this is the new thing you are going to repeat over and over?
replied 2229d
You keep asking for the reasons. You ask me to repeat it in a different way so that you might understand.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Oh, give me a break. I have been very clear that I do not want you to repeat. What I ask you to do is fill the gaping hole in your logic, WITHOUT repeating the faulty logic
replied 2229d
You ask for the reasons, and get given the reasons, and then hand wave away the reasons. Explain how those reasons are not good enough for you.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
You use words like "scale" and think you have explained something. Scale is not an argument. You must explain how the scale makes a difference.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Actually, answer me this. Do I want you to repeat? Have you understood that I want you not to repeat?
White men are people too
replied 2229d
And you should go back and count your own repetitions and be ashamed of yourself for making them. It is very impolite to do this when it has been made clear that it is not helpful.
replied 2229d
If you ever get why these are explanations why you might go back and see how it was being spuoon fed to you, and you just couldn't see it.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
You have now started filling the previous hole that I talked about. You have even started to change your stance by now to something completely different from what it was in the start
replied 2229d
Originally I was talking a out freedom of movement, and how governments shouldn't be able to restrict people from coming and going across the border. Like the EU, but globally.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
All that remains now is to start pretending that this is what you said the whole time. We shall see if you are sufficiently dishonest to go there
replied 2229d
I have not changed on that at all. You have just been saying that chang happen by comparing it to private property.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
OK, that answered that question. You are that dishonest.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Projecting again. And you use my words against me almost immediately after I use them. This stinks of intellectual dishonesty.
replied 2229d
It is mocking, not intellectual dishonesty. Lol
White men are people too
replied 2229d
It really is not easy to understand when you are being honest. Honestly, your logic is so flawed that I cannot tell if you are just trolling at the best of times. Please don't do that.
replied 2229d
My logic has been consistantly and sound. You just keep hand waving things away.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
So this just shows that you are a kid with some big words. You have no idea what you are talking about. You have totally made a fool of yourself.
replied 2229d
These are why. You just dont get that.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Wrong. You left a gaping hole in your argument over and over. As I explained, you chose a c, but you did not prove that the lack of c in B necessarily proved the parallel was faulty
replied 2229d
Scale, and public vs private. B is an individual case, while A is on a larger scale. Private vs public ridership. Which aspects confuse you so I can deal with how they apply.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
They all are attempts to confuse the issue. You can let random people into your country or into your family. They may become "integrated" or not. You have no way of telling.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Still, all those "aspects" are wrong. You can explain them, and I can pick apart your attempts. It should be easy enough.
replied 2229d
Try and do so then
You refuse to refute the ideas. You just keep asserting they are wrong. I am the only one backing what I say with an argument.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
I refuse to make your argument for you and then refute. Is it too much to ask to make a real case for how these "aspects" play out in real life to a difference before I refute?
replied 2229d
I made my arguments. Now refute them. If not then you are incapable.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
So you did not claim above that you could go more in detail on them? Your sentences are botched, not easy to know what you really are trying to say
replied 2229d
Consider I have had to repeat it to you multiple times you should understand the reasons given by now.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Ah, back to repeating. You have not "had to" repeat anything. You have been obnoxious enough to keep repeating after I asked you not to. There are no reasons, you are full of hot air
replied 2229d
You say not to repeat and then ask again for the how those are dissimilar on ways hat make the comparisons meaningless, which makes me repeat the reasons. You cant refute the reasons.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
No, I asked specifically for explanation of HOW your platitudes work in real life to make a difference to my parallel. WITHOUT repetition of the platitudes. You know this
replied 2229d
Yes, and you failed to respond.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
OK, exactly where did you do what I say I asked for here, with me failing to respond?
replied 2229d
When I gave a list of the dissimilar qualities that make comparing those two fall apart on this particular issue. You can either say why those dissimilar qualities dont matter or not.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
OK, so you didn't. You repeated the old things again. You keep avoiding my ABc argument and the red/blue jackets parallel. It is up to you to show it matters first.
replied 2228d
I already explained how your ABc argument was wrong, and corrected it for you. I explained how the quality c was exactly how the two were dissimilar.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
OK, now you are just lying
replied 2228d
Sure... even if you dont like the examples I have given, you should at least try to respond to them. If not it just shows you can not.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
You know that this does not follow. There could be many reasons why I choose not to play your games. To try to score cheap points like that is even more intellectual dishonesty.
replied 2228d
The only intellectual dishonesty is coming from you. You try to claim my arguments are in a different form, and attack that form. Strawman much?
White men are people too
replied 2228d
It might have been, if you were right about that assertion. Point out where I did that in detail. Not vague arm waving. Where exactly did I say what.
replied 2228d
Repeating yourself.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
Since you are probably going to object to that: I can say "Airplanes can't fly because the sky is blue". That is not an argument, I would need to show why the blueness matters
replied 2228d
I did explain why they matter. It explained which qualities were disimilar and how it makes your comparison break down. How much do you need it spoon fed to you?
White men are people too
replied 2228d
All the way to where you get off the platitudes and give an argument.
replied 2228d
I gave a list of disimilar qualities. I have spoon fed the argument to you.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
Yes, you gave me a list of platitudes. No, that is not spoon feeding. It is intellectually dishonest conversation. And I did explain why this is so.
replied 2228d
You gave a strawman of why you think it is so. You have not, because you can not, actually refute why those disimilar qualities make your comparison fail.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
It is your job to show how they make the comparison fail, not mine.
replied 2228d
I did. Quit repeating yourself.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
What you do is indicate it is up to me to fill in the blanks (how blueness messes up air travel) and then refute. This is preposterous.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
And no, it is not sufficient to say "Well, not only is the sky blue, the forest has snakes too". You keep doing this. Platitudes like "scale" are not enlightening to me.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
If instead I were to say "when the sky is blue, the atmosphere gets super hot, so the wings of the plane melt and fall off", then I would have at least a real (albeit poor) argument
White men are people too
replied 2228d
You were on the right track a bit with the aging population argument, except of course you missed that the same could be used for families. At least that was an attempt.
replied 2228d
You should try comparing to a similar style of argument. Your long example has nothing to do with the argument I gave at all.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
You keep making this unfounded assertions. They always show to be wrong when we investigate them. Then you go on to new ones. I think you actually manage to fool yourself with this.
replied 2228d
To use your formula, I explained how your comparison of A and B broke down due to factors c, d, e, and f were disimilar, and it is those qualities that matter when comparing A and B.
replied 2228d
I have not gone on to k
New ones. Funny because you said I was repeating them before. I'm still waiting for any attempt to show why the disimilar qualities I gave were wrong.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
And you might get one, once you show they are relevant.
replied 2228d
Oh I have. Many times. Since you cant refute them though you pretend they didn't happen. I get it. You cant back up your words.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
I did refute it. c, d, e ...k, they are all of the form of my new airplane argument platitudes. It does not matter how many platitudes you add, they are still just platitudes.
replied 2228d
They are not in the form of your airplane argument at all actually. You have yet to actually refute the points. You are just hand waving them away by misinterpreting them.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
OK, if you had a good argument, you would make that one, and stick to it. But never mind that. Pick one here and now and present it properly.
replied 2228d
Quit repeating yourself.
White men are people too
replied 2228d
Pick your best argument and repeat it here. As if you mean it.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
But the reason is clear enough. You tried to show how it did not make sense, and failed, and now you instead try to pretend there is an argument there that you will not tell me about
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Maybe you missed my argument that "scale" is not an argument. You must explain how scale plays a role. Hence my ABc argument, which you seem to have forgotten.
replied 2229d
We did get to why scale matters actually. When you talked about letting a bump in your home, and I said it wouldn't matter if your home had millions of people already.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
If I don't get you to make the argument first, you will change your stance after the fact and pretend that the new stance was your stance all along, as you have shown willing to do
White men are people too
replied 2229d
They may help your economy or they may break it. They may help you when you get old, or they may rob you blind. You just don't know. You act as if there is certainty they will be good
White men are people too
replied 2229d
Also, the repetition is still impolite.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
I am repeating my message until you hear it. You are repeating your message after I have said you are just repeating stuff I have answered. Two very different things
replied 2229d
I was repeating my message until you would hear it. You wont though because you cant let go of bad ideas.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
You repeat something over and over after being told you are just repeating, and when opposition has to repeat that you are just repeating you cry foul? Intellectually honest?
replied 2229d
Which is it, was I repeating the reasons, or jotngivjng reasons. You cant have it both ways.
White men are people too
replied 2229d
You were repeating the same fallacy over and over. Call it reasons if you like, but there was no explanation.
replied 2229d
That is not how you use the word fallacy. Especially in response to your false equivalency.


About Privacy Terms Stats